Which is the correct objection to the question ‘Mama Bear, isn’t it true you never make cookies?’

Which is the correct objection to the question ‘Mama Bear, isn’t it true you never make cookies?’

• A. Irrelevant
• B. Leading Question
• C. Hearsay
• D. Speculation

Answer: (A)

Relevance is the key idea. A question or piece of testimony must tend to prove or disprove a material fact in the case. Asking if Mama Bear never bakes cookies is probing a personal habit that, on its own, does not connect to any issue the jury needs to decide. It doesn’t help establish liability, guilt, bias, or any element of the claim or defense, and it doesn’t tend to make any material fact more or less probable. Unless the case hinges on cookies or on a specific issue tied to that habit, the question lacks relevance and should be objected to on that ground. If there were a clear, material link—like a claim that she baked cookies on a particular occasion involved in the case—then the line of questioning might become relevant, but as stated it does not.

Relevance is the key idea. A question or piece of testimony must tend to prove or disprove a material fact in the case. Asking if Mama Bear never bakes cookies is probing a personal habit that, on its own, does not connect to any issue the jury needs to decide. It doesn’t help establish liability, guilt, bias, or any element of the claim or defense, and it doesn’t tend to make any material fact more or less probable. Unless the case hinges on cookies or on a specific issue tied to that habit, the question lacks relevance and should be objected to on that ground. If there were a clear, material link—like a claim that she baked cookies on a particular occasion involved in the case—then the line of questioning might become relevant, but as stated it does not.